Are we talking too much about the Holocaust?

Posted by Olivier Melnick on December 1, 2016

We live at a time when Jewish people are being accused of dwelling unnecessarily on the memory of the Holocaust   . But at the same time we are seeing swastikas being painted on doors, walls and even tombstones, globally.

Mahmoud Abbas was unanimously re-elected as leader of Fatah and the West is supposed to get excited about the man who they believe could make peace with Israel. Let us not forget that he is a Holocaust denier and has written his thesis in 1982 on that very topic under the title: The Connection between the Nazis and the Leaders of the Zionist Movement.

Populist parties are gaining tremendous ground in Europe as the desire to stop and control the migrant crisis becomes a priority. With them, they bring the deep rooted European racial antisemitism that we thought was defunct.

It was only a couple of years ago that I was on the streets of Paris hearing people marching and chanting “Jews to the ovens.” It really seems that a lot of people are either denying the Holocaust, wanting another one or worse… are clueless about the first one!

I don’t think that we speak too much of the Holocaust but I think that we don’t speak about it in its proper context.

Scholars, philosophers, theologians and historians have all grappled with the Holocaust, trying to come to terms with the immensity of its evil in strength and scope. Some within classical Jewish religious thought believe that the Holocaust was God’s retribution or “pay-back” for Israel’s sins. In other words, it was God’s desire to discipline Israel for her sins and as such, was part of God’s plan all along.

The common name for it is Mi-penei hata ‘ einu (Hebrew for “because of our sins we were punished.”) It refers to Divine punishment for the sins of Israel. It is true that the Tenach is replete with stories about the sins of Israel and their consequential discipline from God.

Holocaust survivor and Nobel Prize laureate, Elie Wiesel wrote in 1962 of the religious Jewish reaction to the Holocaust in Commentary Magazine: The feeling of guilt was, to begin with, essentially a religious feeling. If I am here, it is because God is punishing me; I have sinned, and I am expiating my sins. I have deserved this punishment that I am suffering.[1]

Wiesel, along with many others, feel that while the punishment inflicted by the Holocaust might not be proportionate to the sins committed by Israel, but they are related. Incidentally, if one believes that–as the Bible teaches–the price for our sins is death (Ezekiel 18:4), then the Holocaust could be justified. But why would God wait almost two thousand years to punish Israel, and why inflict pain and suffering on generations that are so far removed from the previous ones?

Others will see Israel as the Suffering Servant of Isaiah 52:13-53:12. They will assign the suffering of the Holocaust to all Israel (all Jewish people.) While it is beyond the scope of this article to discuss the meaning of the Isaiah 53 chapter, it’ll simply be stated that this controversial passage definitely speaks of suffering, humiliation and death in no uncertain terms, but it can also refer to a person and not Israel as a whole. If indeed it refers to a person in particular, Yeshua of Nazareth is the only one who would fit that description, especially since towards the end of the passage after humiliation, suffering and death comes resurrection.

Some speak of Hester Panim (“hiding of the face,”) also known as “the eclipse of God.” Psalm 44:23-24 speak of God hiding His face: Arouse Yourself, why do You sleep, O Lord? Awake, do not reject us forever.Why do You hide Your face And forget our affliction and our oppression?

Was God absent during the Holocaust? From the standpoint of protecting the victims from suffering and death, it would certainly appear to be true. Each and every one of the six-million innocent victims–if they could speak– would most likely testify of God’s absence or lack of involvement.

Yet, when we speak of the eclipse of God, we must recall what an eclipse is all about; a visual disappearance while the physical presence remains. In other words, God might have been eclipsed or might have been hiding His face during the Holocaust, but He was always there and always within reach. Not always was He there, but He felt the pain of the victims as Isaiah 63:9 tells us: In all their affliction He was afflicted, And the angel of His presence saved them; In His love and in His mercy He redeemed them,

Many religious people, Jewish and gentiles ended up in the camps. If God was silent, some of His people weren’t.  The eclipse of God was not because He didn’t care but possibly because for a time, He removed Himself from the affairs of men, leaving the fate of many in the hands of a few. At the very least, He allowed for the Jewish people not to be under His protection like He had done repeatedly in the long history of the children of Israel.

Isaiah tells us that God cared as he suffered affliction for His people. Additionally, God took no pleasure in the death of the many. Even assuming that Israel was being punished by the Holocaust for being wicked–a case that cannot be made with absolute certainty– the prophet Ezekiel speaks of God when he writes: Say to them, ‘As I live!’ declares the Lord God, ‘I take no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but rather that the wicked turn from his way and live.

Maybe the Holocaust is simply the proof that God is dead. That is the conclusion made by most Jewish people who survived the Holocaust or were born after 1945. Again Elie Wiesel, this time in his seminal work Night, depicts the agonizing hanging of a young boy: “Where is God? Where is He?” someone behind me asked…. For more than half an hour [the child in the noose] stayed there, struggling between life and death, dying in slow agony under our eyes. And we had to look him full in the face. He was still alive when I passed in front of him. His tongue was still red, his eyes were not yet glazed. Behind me, I heard the same man asking: “Where is God now?” And I heard a voice within me answer him: “Where is He? Here He is—He is hanging here on this gallows.”[2]

But if God died during the Holocaust, why did it come to a halt in 1945? The Nazi war machine was well oiled and extremely efficient. The liberation of the Camps and the capitulation of Germany would militate towards God not being dead and on the contrary being instrumental in the end of World War Two. This is also in line with His promise to never completely destroy Israel as found in the prophet Jeremiah (Jer. 31:35-37.)

I could continue to look at the Holocaust and wrestle further with causes for it. Regardless of how many approaches with come up with, we will most certainly come back to evil being at the core of the “Catastrophe.”

This lead us to the problem of evil. The existence of evil in the world is something that is highly debated. Very few believe that evil doesn’t exist. The Holocaust and how low humanity could bring itself were a proof that evil exists.

Hitler wasn’t insane, which would exonerate him of all responsibility for the “Final Solution to the Jewish problem.” Hitler was pure evil! But even when we recognize that, the source of all evil still has to be identified.

I don’t believe that we can properly do such a thing without building our case on a biblical foundation. Morality is based on the balance between good and evil which is best brought forward by looking at what the Tenach says.

Good and evil cannot exist independently of one another since one defines the other. Going back to the very first book of the Tenach, Genesis, we find out that one of God’s most special angels, Satan, rebelled against God and fell from grace. From that point on, he has been working very hard at hating what God loves and loving what God hates. That puts the Jewish people and Israel directly in his crosshairs.

He knows that through the Jewish people, more specifically through the tribe of Judah (Gen 49:10,) will come the Redeemer of mankind, the Messiah of Israel. His goal is to stop that from happening, because at some point in the future, Messiah will put an end to Satan’s career and he doesn’t care for his retirement plan.

I am often asked if the birth of the modern state of Israel is a direct result of World War Two and the Holocaust. I believe that the answer is NO! Rather, the Holocaust was an attempt by Satan to destroy the Jews right before they would start fulfilling one of God’s most amazing prophecy about their return to their biblical land (Ezekiel 36-38.)

There is no doubt in my mind that Satan was aware of the return of the Jews to Israel in the End-Times. He had to stop it, or at least try, thus the Holocaust. He used Pharaoh to try to stop Moses from being born, he used Herod to try to stop Yeshua from being born and he used Nazi Germany and Hitler to try to stop the Jews from moving back to Israel and fulfill God’s covenantal promises. Satan exploited the fact that the Jewish people weren’t under God’s protection and were more at the mercy of the nations to attempt their total eradication. He almost succeeded but God is greater. Not only God is greater but He is interested in every single soul that exists. God wants to draw them to Him, one soul at a time.

So again, it is not that we speak too much of the Holocaust, but maybe that we speak of it in the wrong context.


[2] Elie Wiesel: Night (New York: Hilland Wang, 1960) 75-76

Sign-Up for Newletter

Comments ...

10 comments on “Are we talking too much about the Holocaust?”

  1. Thank you for all the great work your doing. I shared this article on my FB page as it's the least I can do.

  2. No! The Holocaust should be taught always. When we foget we allow it to happen again. Millions of innocent men, children, women, old and your plus the herOscar that worked to save them died underror horrendous circumstances for what! Ideology? Brilliant.
    I have read every book on the Holocaust I could get my hands on, am still reading, trying to understand WHY WHY did people hate the Jew. I went to Dachau, I wept, and people wanTed to know why this was so important to me. (No, as far as I know I am not Jewish although nothing would make me prouder). I had the privilege of talking to my grandchildren about the Holocaust, as they were learning about it in school. We must NEVER FORGET WHAT THE WORLD ALLOWED to happen to innocent people

  3. Oh my no...people must keep trying to tell & educate people on the HORROR of the awful Holocaust!!! Too many wicked one's trying to deny it & even more trying to ignite another one. I learn all I can on matter HOW much it BREAKS MY HEART!! The Dear LORD GOD has given me a federal LOVE for Jews & Israel...& ofcoarse Jerusalem. May the God of Abraham, Isaac, & Jacob pprotect the Jewish beloved precious

  4. No, the Holocaust needs to be remembered, as do all man-made atrocities. There is something else that needs to be discussed.

    While not diminishing the enormous cost to the Jewish people, society needs to equally recognize that they are not the only people to perish, nor is the Holocaust the only atrocity which took the lives of millions. Every human atrocity should be equally remembered, as each human life taken was precious.

    The question should be asked why is there still so much emphasis on the Holocaust and not as much toward other human atrocities such as what happened in Russia under Stalin, China under Mao or Cambodia under Pol Pot. Or the atrocity on Rwawanda. How about the complete massacre of Native populations in both the US and Canada? The residential schools in Canada, where the following generations of the native population there have yet to recover? Or what is currently occurring in Syria, etc with the annihilation of Christians?

    In closing, I feel we are doing the remembrance of the Holocaust by diminishing the other mass murder of people, be it great or small by putting such an unbalanced focus on it. Perhaps to best way forward, for any person who has experienced tragedy in their lives (this writer included), is to learn to forgive, determine to overcome tragedy by not only living, but thriving, while remembering the past for the sole purpose that others may learn.

    Shabbat shalom to all.


    1. Sorry, I meant "...we do a gross disservice to the Holocaust...".

      Also by complete massacre of populations of the native people in both the US and Canada, this writer meant certain tribes have been completely obliterated, such as the Beothuk in Newfoundland.

  5. A reply to the Trackback.

    I am immediately reminded of the time when Binyamin (Benjamin) was almost completely annihilated by the rest of the tribes for allowing the savage rape of a Levite's concubine (Judges 19). In this story, there was a righteous anger that rose up among the other tribes regarding the fate of the concubine. Was Elohim dead when He destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah for their unrighteousness? No, He wasn't. He destroyed the two cities and surrounding areas due to the gross filth and subsequent cries of the innocent. And He most certainly was not dead when the Holocaust took place. I think we forget that YHWH is an Elohim of at once righteousness and justice, of mercy and compassion and also jealousy and anger. He is quick to forgive, long suffering, but will by no means pardon the guilty.

    He has a standard that He has for His people (not talking about the Jewish people, but also Christians), and He expects us to uphold the standard. At the same time, in His mercy, He saved alive eight people on an ark, Lot and his two daughters during the destruction of Sodom, Gomorrah et al, eventually the Israelites won over Binyamin, but not before a tithe was taken, and even during the Holocaust, there are many stories of mercy and compassion shown also.

    Who are we to ascribe our human understanding of what is right, just, merciful, compassion, jealousy and anger, and their reasons therefore. Indeed His thoughts are higher than ours, His ways higher than ours. He has written His standards in His Torah, with the outworking of the same witnessed in the New Covenant (2 Tim 3:16).

    I believe ours is to seek His face as to not so much why, but what, as in what does He require of us.

    Shabbat shalom.

  6. Thanks, I agree.
    The concret geopolitical process of the Israël return on his Land started with WW1 with the end of Ottoman's Empire. The Land of Isräel has been released from Islamic hegemony. The official birth of Israël was effective on 1920 in San Remo during the "post-World War I Allied Supreme Council". At this point, the possible return of the Messiah was also "official" on the hearth, because Yeshua have to come in the midst of his people. it is clear that the devil did'nt like that.

    Making an enphasis on the sins of Isräel to explain the holocaust, is, in my sens, a kind of hate of the people of Isräel. Eli Wisel could not understand the prophetic view of what was happened. The debts to God give a kind of sense to this horror. We need sense to survive and propably this only one he found.

    We need to share this point of view particulary to the christian's people.
    I share on my facebook page.

  7. geee, there are 56 Holocaust MUSEUM alone in the USA. Not to mention several Holocaust movies a year cranked out by Hollywood.

    Meanwhile people know nothing about the Holodomor, when 8 million Ukrainians were slaughtered by Jews.

    Never forget? Pffff, 1 MILLION Iraqi civillians were blown to bits in the Iraq war, (Iraq didn't attack us on 911). Let alone the poor Iraqi Christians who suffered as a result 2003, Christians in Iraq 1, 400,000 -- 2016, Christians in Iraq 275,000

    Sorry if we don't care as much about atrocities from 75 years ago as we do about things going on today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shalom in Messiah

We are a non-profit organization that exists to expose and fight antisemitism, as well as to equip and mobilize Christians to lead the Jewish people to the Messiah.
Copyright © 2024 Shalom in Messiah Ministries
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram